Tuesday, May 31, 2005

when bad thinking happens to good people...

Here's an example of the superficial thinking that plagues political thinking. The caption in the picture reads "we get to the point". But what, exactly, is the point? We know that:
1. the Middle East has oil. And,
2. the U.S. uses oil. And,
3. the U.S. has troops in the Middle East.

For many people, these three propositions somehow cohere into a necessary causal relationship, i.e. sentiments such as "No blood for oil." Now, I see how these 3 propositions are tangentially related: the word "oil" is in 1 + 2, the word "U.S." is in 2 + 3, and the word "Middle East" is in 1 + 3. And apparently, that's the extent of the analysis needed.

But every economist says that the best guarantee of cheap oil is to coddle Middle East dictators and always maintain the status quo. In other words, the best way to get cheap oil is to never interfere in the Middle East. Basically the opposite of the theory that is exemplified by this advertisement. Nevermind, that kind of thinking doesn't fit on a poster.

- dane

3 Comments:

Blogger The Wissy said...

Well illustrated, Mr. Shelly.

This is precisely the sort of slippery thinking that made Fahrenheit 9/11 a big success with adoring audiences and an infuriating miss with penetrating minds like C. Hitchens and yourself.

When you're working with images (this German ad, M. Moore, and Adbusters) it is easy to get away with shoddy logic.

I know I had not properly made the connection until now. Thank you.

--Ted

4:17 PM  
Anonymous Chirol said...

Many thanks for the excellent run down!

3:50 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a tiger t shirtcompany called Holden Tees. We're a small company and we sell shirts and stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time

-Holden Tees

8:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home